<-- Google Analytics START --> <-- Google Analytics END -->

john davies
notes from a small vicar
from a parish
in Liverpool, UK

    Tuesday, June 07, 2005
    Whose idea of paradise

    Peace - Music - Ecology
    Liberty - Community - Democracy
    Alternatives - Knowledge - Altruism

    [- from Woodstock]

    "What," asked the young woman this afternoon, "is your idea of paradise?"

    We were having a picnic lunch together, we and twenty others, on the top of Paradise Street Car Park. Which was why she asked the question.

    Jean Grant had got us together - a mixed bag of city planners, punters, regeneration people, on this soon-to-be-demolished concrete slab, to look out over the enormous tract of reclaimed land which is The Paradise Project, and contemplate its meaning.

    Some people's idea of paradise involved fine wine and sunkissed islands. Mine was closer to the Woodstock ideal, not so much a physical place as a state of (well-) being. As the cranes swung overhead and down below, on the once-green Chavasse Park, men stood ankle-deep in mud surveying plans, I couldn't help thinking of Joni Mitchell's words:

    They paved paradise and put up a parking lot,
    With a pink hotel, a boutique,
    And a swinging hot spot.
    Don't it always seem to go
    That you don't know what you've got till it's gone?
    They paved paradise and put up a parking lot.

    Actually it's naive to assume that this area has ever been paradise to anyone except nineteenth century sailors seeking the company of women. Ron's website informs us that a guidebook of 1816 advised visitors of the "spectacle of vice and misery in their lowest forms" on view in Paradise Street. And he names Maggie May, Tich Maguire, Mary Ellen, "The Battleship", Harriet Lane, Jumping Jenny, Cast-Iron Kitty and "The Dreadnought" - all famous prostitutes who hung around Paradise Street or Lime Street in those times.

    Paradise Street was one of the streets between the centre and the docks where brothels and pubs were particularly numerous, Francois Poirier writes, and "Liverpool was the seaman's heaven when New York was not, and Americans were seen by Liverpudlians as easy prey... No surprise then, that the fact of having been to Liverpool was the badge of manhood for the American sailors: if they survived it, they were truly Yanks."

    Out of all that rough stuff came a massive canon of shanties celebrating the raw life of the sea, many mentioning Paradise Street by name. The inevitable casualties of such extreme living were offered refuge and respite in the celebrated Paradise Street Sailors' Home, and The Mersey Mission to Seamen just around the corner.

    residential - retail - business
    John Lewis - Debenhams - Q-Park
    restaurant - wine bar - gallery

    [ - from The Paradise Project website]

    A flagship John Lewis store is planned for the site of the Sailors' Home. The Moat House hotel has already gone, Radio Merseyside and the Friends Meeting house will follow in a few months, and by the time we have our Iona Community Regional Plenary on the subject of cultural regeneration the view we had today will have vastly altered - from acres of concrete foundations the new Debenhams will be rising high.

    All this on the site of the old pool, Jean's subject of exploration, the waterway which attracted the settlement which became this city. This area has always been at the heart of the commercial life of Liverpool, and it's carrying on that way. But, has it ever, will it ever, be anywhere like paradise?